Who Gets to Keep the House in a Daytona Beach Divorce When Both Spouses Are on the Mortgage?

A couple may agree that one spouse will stay in the family home after divorce. But when both names are on the mortgage, that agreement does not necessarily end the other spouse’s financial responsibility. The divorce court can decide who receives the house and who should make the payments. The lender, however, is not automatically bound by those decisions.

How Florida Courts Decide Who Gets the Home

Florida follows equitable distribution under section 61.075 of the Florida Statutes. Courts generally begin with the presumption that marital assets and debts should be divided equally, unless circumstances justify a different distribution. The house is often one of the largest assets to address, but the court must consider the entire marital estate rather than deciding who gets the property in isolation.

A judge may consider each spouse’s economic circumstances, contributions to the marriage, the interests of minor children, and whether keeping the home intact is practical. In some cases, one spouse receives the property and compensates the other for their share of the equity. In others, selling the house and dividing the net proceeds is the more workable solution.

The Mortgage Does Not Disappear With the Divorce

The deed and the mortgage serve different purposes. The deed establishes ownership, while the mortgage loan documents establish who promised to repay the lender. Signing a quitclaim deed or receiving the house under a divorce judgment does not, by itself, remove a spouse from the loan.

If both spouses remain borrowers and payments are missed, the lender may pursue the borrowers according to the loan terms, even if the divorce agreement assigns payment responsibility to only one of them. A spouse who is ordered to pay may face consequences in family court for violating the judgment, but that does not prevent damage to the other borrower’s credit or eliminate the lender’s rights.

Can One Spouse Refinance and Keep the House?

Refinancing the mortgage into the name of the spouse keeping the home is one way to separate the loan obligations. The challenge is qualification. A lender will evaluate income, credit, debts, and the property’s value. A spouse who could afford the payments when two incomes supported the household may not qualify alone.

A settlement should address what happens if refinancing is denied or cannot be completed by the agreed deadline. Depending on the circumstances, the spouses might agree to sell the home, extend a deadline, or explore whether the lender offers an approved loan assumption or release of liability. None of these alternatives should be presumed available without lender confirmation.

What If Neither Spouse Can Afford to Keep It?

Selling the property may be necessary when neither spouse can carry the mortgage, insurance, taxes, maintenance, and other housing costs alone. Before agreeing to a sale, the couple should determine the mortgage payoff, estimated closing costs, and any liens that could reduce the proceeds. If the home has little equity—or is worth less than the outstanding debt—the negotiations may be more complicated.

A divorce agreement can also spell out who will live in the home while it is listed, who will pay the expenses, how the asking price may be adjusted, and how the net proceeds or remaining obligations will be handled.

Steps to Take Before Agreeing to Keep the House

For homeowners in Daytona Beach and elsewhere in Volusia County, a few documents can clarify the options before a settlement is signed:

  • A current mortgage statement showing the balance, payment, and names of the borrowers.
  • A reliable estimate of the home’s market value and any other liens.
  • Records of property taxes, homeowners insurance, association fees, and expected maintenance costs.
  • Information about each spouse’s income, credit, and ability to refinance.
  • Proposed deadlines and a backup plan if the mortgage cannot be transferred or refinanced.

The question is not simply which spouse wants the home. It is whether the proposed arrangement protects both parties financially after the marriage ends.

Discuss Your Property Division Options

At Wickersham & Bowers, we help clients in Daytona Beach and the surrounding Volusia County area work through property division, mortgage obligations, and divorce settlements. We can review the financial details and help you evaluate whether keeping or selling the family home makes sense. Contact us or call 386-252-3000 to discuss your situation.

Contact The Law Office of

Wickersham & Bowers

    Let's Talk
    About Your Legal Matter

    Contact Us